Most therapists have felt stuck when working with a client.

You’ve tried different interventions. You’ve explored the barriers. You’ve validated, challenged, problem-solved, and gone back to the drawing board. And still, nothing seems to change.

That’s often when the judgmental thoughts start creeping in.

They aren’t doing the work.

They say they want things to change, but then they keep doing the same thing.

We’ve talked about this so many times.

Why do they agree to something in session and then never follow through?

Having these thoughts doesn’t make us bad therapists. But they may tell us something important: we’re frustrated, we’re stuck, and the way we’re understanding the client’s behavior may no longer be helping us help them.

Sometimes, what looks like resistance or treatment-interfering behavior makes more sense when we understand it as a trauma response.

When “Resistance” Is a Response to Threat

Trauma responses in therapy don’t always look like obvious fear or distress. Fight, flight, freeze, and fawn are often discussed as responses to obvious danger. But for people with histories of trauma, particularly chronic or relational trauma, the nervous system can respond to situations that feel threatening even when there is no immediate physical danger.

Therapy can contain plenty of those situations.

Being vulnerable can feel threatening. Being asked to change a behavior that has served a protective function can feel threatening. Disagreeing with a therapist can feel threatening. So can disappointing them. Even being asked to notice what is happening inside the body can feel unsafe for someone who learned long ago that disconnecting from their body was protective.

When we look through that lens, behaviors that initially appear resistant may start to look different.

A client who becomes argumentative or challenges every suggestion may be moving into fight.

A client who repeatedly changes the subject, misses sessions, avoids homework, or steers away from painful material may be experiencing flight.

A client who suddenly goes blank, can’t answer a question, shuts down, or repeatedly says “I don’t know” may be experiencing freeze.

And the client who agrees with every intervention, tells us exactly what they think we want to hear, and then struggles to follow through outside the session may be relying on fawn.

None of this means we can assume that every difficult therapy behavior is caused by trauma. It does mean that when treatment is stuck, it may be worth asking what function the behavior is before deciding that the client simply isn’t motivated.

Trauma-Informed Doesn’t Mean Anything Goes

Recognizing trauma responses in therapy doesn’t mean that every behavior should be accommodated or excused. Understanding a behavior as a trauma response does not mean ignoring it. It also doesn’t mean eliminating expectations, avoiding difficult conversations, or becoming so concerned about activating a client that therapy itself stops moving forward.

A behavior can be both understandable and treatment-interfering.

That dialectic is especially important in DBT. We can validate why a behavior developed and recognize the function it serves while also helping the client build more effective ways of responding.

The question shifts from:

Why won’t this client do what we’ve discussed?

to:

What happens for this client when we ask them to do it?

That question gives us somewhere to go.

Therapist Frustration Can Become Part of the Cycle

There is another piece of this that can be harder to examine: our own response to the client.

When we feel ineffective, worried, frustrated, or burned out, our behavior can change too.

We may push harder. Repeat ourselves. Become more directive. Pull back emotionally. Lower our expectations. Over-accommodate. Or find ourselves feeling increasingly irritated by behaviors we initially understood with compassion.

The client notices.

For someone whose nervous system is already sensitive to rejection, criticism, conflict, disappointment, or loss of connection, even subtle changes in the therapist can increase the sense of threat.

Then the protective behavior intensifies.

The therapist becomes more frustrated.

And suddenly, both people are caught in a cycle that neither one intended to create.

Recognizing that cycle isn’t about blaming the therapist—or the client. It gives us an opportunity to interrupt it.

Getting Curious When Therapy Feels Stuck

When we begin to suspect that we may be seeing trauma responses in therapy, curiosity can be more useful than judgment.

Asking:

What happens immediately before this behavior?

What might the client be experiencing as threatening?

What function does the behavior serve?

What happens inside me when the client responds this way?

And how might my response inadvertently reinforce the cycle?

Sometimes the question that helps therapy begin moving again isn’t:

How do I get this client to stop doing this?

It’s:

What is this behavior doing for them—and what happens between us when it shows up?

Of course, that shift doesn’t solve every treatment impasse. But it can open up possibilities that are difficult to see when both therapist and client are stuck.

Want to Explore This Further?

On September 17, 2026, I’ll be presenting When Trauma Looks Like Treatment-Interfering Behavior: Understanding Fight, Flight, Freeze, and Fawn in DBT through the Rebel Minds Learning Collective.

In this two-hour live online training, we’ll look more closely at how trauma-related threat responses can appear in therapy, how they can be mistaken for resistance or treatment-interfering behavior, and strategies for responding in ways that remain both trauma-informed and behaviorally effective.

The training will be held on September 17 from 3–5 PM ET via Zoom, with 2 NBCC and ASWB continuing education credits available for live attendance.

Register for the training through Rebel Minds Learning Collective.

My New Eating Disorder Recovery Workbook Arrives November 10th